Wise Children by Angela Carter
Give Angela Carter credit--she didn't brag without justification. Her writing, as it turns out, really does "cut like a steel blade at the base of a man's penis" (admittedly, I don't have any personal experience with which to make a comparison). I'd like to quote a passage from Wise Children to illustrate just what a fantastic writer she was, but I'm spoiled for choice. Open the book at any random page and you're almost guaranteed to find something quotable. Here, try this from the opening chapter:
If this all sounds ridiculously theatrical, it's meant to. Melchior, Dora, and Nora are descended from theatre royalty--the august Ranulph Hazard and his irrepressible child-bride, Estella (they met when she played Cordelia to his Lear, which neatly sets up not only the many Shakespearean parallels in the book, but also the recurring themes of May/December romances and genteel incest). Melchior himself is also a giant of the theatre, whereas his daughters are song-and-dance girls who tread the boards of dance halls in everything from dance reviews to striptease acts. Wise Children is a novel full of such contradictions--legitimate children versus illegitimate ones, respectable theatre versus low burlesque, comedy versus tragedy.
As Dora narrates her life, we follow her and her sister from humble beginnings as chorus girls and hoofers, to the apex of their career in a Hollywood version of A Midsummer Night's Dream starring their father (in an obvious parallel to Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor, Melchior falls passionately in love with his leading lady, the producer's wife, and they abandon their respective spouses for a tempestuous and short-lived marriage as the film goes to pieces around them), to a quiet life teaching children to dance and occasionally selling off a memento of their show-business past to pay the heating bill. There's nothing sad or wistful about Wise Children, however, nor indeed about Dora and Nora themselves. They have regrets, lost loves, failed ambitions, but as they wake up on the morning of their seventy-fifth birthday, each sister is ready for her life to begin again.
And begin it does. The day starts off with a tragedy, as the sisters discover that their beloved goddaughter has been jilted by her lover, Melchior's son, and may have drowned herself. You can always count on the Chance sisters to turn a frown upside down, however, and on Carter herself--for all the tragedy she throws in her characters' paths, Wise Children is an extraordinarily funny book. Every kind of funny--from acid wit through double entendres to broad farce. As much as I admired Carter's The Bloody Chamber, a collection of retold and reimagined fairy tales, there was a defensiveness to it that was hard to ignore. Yes, these are fairy tales, Carter seemed to be saying, but look! Sex, violence, gore, depravity! The Bloody Chamber exuded the desperate determination of a young person to be accepted as an adult and leave childish things behind them. In Wise Children, Carter's last novel, she seems to have come full circle. Her voice is that of a mature woman who recognizes that nothing is as serious as comedy, or as adult as the heartbreak and tribulations of childhood.
Wise Children's denouement takes place as the sisters attend their father's birthday gala. It's a side-splitting and heartbreaking scene, during the course of which several long-lost and presumed-dead relatives will reappear, the paternity of several children will be brought to light, a wronged woman will publicly condemn her fickle lover, a deserting husband will be made to acknowledge his true wife, ungrateful children will be punished and grateful ones rewarded, and the entire party will be served a poisoned desert.
This is all from Shakespeare, of course--or, perhaps, all of Shakespeare. There is hardly a play in The Bard's repertoire that Carter doesn't riff off, reference, or lampoon, and the book is riddled with references to Shakespeare himself--Dora and Nora's house, for example, is on Bard Road. Discovering these parallels and references--many of which, I'm sure, flew right over my head--is half the fun of reading the book, as are the ways in which Carter manages to put a modern spin on so many of Shakespeare's plots.
Wise Children is a book about the search for identity, and about the ability--and the need--to reinvent yourself. When Dora takes Nora's name for a night, the usually quiet sister finds herself mimicking, and even becoming, her exuberant and vivacious twin. Nora, on the other hand, quickly forgets to behave like Dora, and soon gives her sister a reputation as a flirt. It is a wise child, Carter tells us, who knows its own father, but for Dora and Nora Chance, wisdom is found in knowing themselves, and in being known by others. Surrounded by theatrical people, who see their lives as a series of dramatic climaxes and tragic setbacks, it is the Chance sisters who recognize that real life is simply a sequence of events without plot or resolution. The secret, the sisters know, is to hope for the best, prepare for the worst, and always be ready for a new beginning.
"You can see for miles, out of this window. You can see straight across the river. There's Westminster Abbey, see? Flying the St. George's cross, today. St. Paul's, the single breast. Big Ben, winking its golden eye. Not much else familiar, these days. This is about the time that comes in every century when they reach out for all that they can grab of dear old London, and pull it down. Then they build it up again, like London Bridge in the nursery rhyme, goodbye, hello, but it's never the same. Even the railway stations, changed out of recognition, turned into souks. Waterloo, Victoria. Nowhere you can get a decent cup of tea, all they give you is Harvey Wallbangers, filthy capuccino. Stocking shops and knicker outlets everywhere you look. I said to Nora: 'Remember Brief Encounter, how I cried buckets? Nowhere for them to meet on a station, nowadays, except in a bloody knicker shop. Their hands would have to shyly touch under cover of a pair of Union Jack boxer shorts.'"This is the wary and experienced, but by no means tired, voice of Dora Chance as she describes the events of her seventy-fifth birthday, which also happens to be the one hundredth birthday of her illustrious father, Melchior Hazard. Dora and her twin sister Nora are Melchior's illegitimate daughters by a nameless chambermaid (or was their mother, in fact, the woman they knew as Grandma?), and their father has never acknowledged them even in private. Despite this, the sisters' lives, professional and personal, have been inextricably bound with Melchior's and his family's--his twin brother Peregrine, as generous with his affections as Melchior is stingy with his; his three wives; his twin daughters by his first wife and twin sons by his third.
If this all sounds ridiculously theatrical, it's meant to. Melchior, Dora, and Nora are descended from theatre royalty--the august Ranulph Hazard and his irrepressible child-bride, Estella (they met when she played Cordelia to his Lear, which neatly sets up not only the many Shakespearean parallels in the book, but also the recurring themes of May/December romances and genteel incest). Melchior himself is also a giant of the theatre, whereas his daughters are song-and-dance girls who tread the boards of dance halls in everything from dance reviews to striptease acts. Wise Children is a novel full of such contradictions--legitimate children versus illegitimate ones, respectable theatre versus low burlesque, comedy versus tragedy.
As Dora narrates her life, we follow her and her sister from humble beginnings as chorus girls and hoofers, to the apex of their career in a Hollywood version of A Midsummer Night's Dream starring their father (in an obvious parallel to Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor, Melchior falls passionately in love with his leading lady, the producer's wife, and they abandon their respective spouses for a tempestuous and short-lived marriage as the film goes to pieces around them), to a quiet life teaching children to dance and occasionally selling off a memento of their show-business past to pay the heating bill. There's nothing sad or wistful about Wise Children, however, nor indeed about Dora and Nora themselves. They have regrets, lost loves, failed ambitions, but as they wake up on the morning of their seventy-fifth birthday, each sister is ready for her life to begin again.
And begin it does. The day starts off with a tragedy, as the sisters discover that their beloved goddaughter has been jilted by her lover, Melchior's son, and may have drowned herself. You can always count on the Chance sisters to turn a frown upside down, however, and on Carter herself--for all the tragedy she throws in her characters' paths, Wise Children is an extraordinarily funny book. Every kind of funny--from acid wit through double entendres to broad farce. As much as I admired Carter's The Bloody Chamber, a collection of retold and reimagined fairy tales, there was a defensiveness to it that was hard to ignore. Yes, these are fairy tales, Carter seemed to be saying, but look! Sex, violence, gore, depravity! The Bloody Chamber exuded the desperate determination of a young person to be accepted as an adult and leave childish things behind them. In Wise Children, Carter's last novel, she seems to have come full circle. Her voice is that of a mature woman who recognizes that nothing is as serious as comedy, or as adult as the heartbreak and tribulations of childhood.
Wise Children's denouement takes place as the sisters attend their father's birthday gala. It's a side-splitting and heartbreaking scene, during the course of which several long-lost and presumed-dead relatives will reappear, the paternity of several children will be brought to light, a wronged woman will publicly condemn her fickle lover, a deserting husband will be made to acknowledge his true wife, ungrateful children will be punished and grateful ones rewarded, and the entire party will be served a poisoned desert.
This is all from Shakespeare, of course--or, perhaps, all of Shakespeare. There is hardly a play in The Bard's repertoire that Carter doesn't riff off, reference, or lampoon, and the book is riddled with references to Shakespeare himself--Dora and Nora's house, for example, is on Bard Road. Discovering these parallels and references--many of which, I'm sure, flew right over my head--is half the fun of reading the book, as are the ways in which Carter manages to put a modern spin on so many of Shakespeare's plots.
Wise Children is a book about the search for identity, and about the ability--and the need--to reinvent yourself. When Dora takes Nora's name for a night, the usually quiet sister finds herself mimicking, and even becoming, her exuberant and vivacious twin. Nora, on the other hand, quickly forgets to behave like Dora, and soon gives her sister a reputation as a flirt. It is a wise child, Carter tells us, who knows its own father, but for Dora and Nora Chance, wisdom is found in knowing themselves, and in being known by others. Surrounded by theatrical people, who see their lives as a series of dramatic climaxes and tragic setbacks, it is the Chance sisters who recognize that real life is simply a sequence of events without plot or resolution. The secret, the sisters know, is to hope for the best, prepare for the worst, and always be ready for a new beginning.
Comments
it's a good book, an excellent book, i just wish they'd make a guide of some sort running next to each page explaining EVERY allusion!
good review though, got it down to a tee.
ive ogt n exam on it tommorow
thankyou
thankyou
thankyou
thankyou
thankyou
marry me please?
Beau
This was a great book, and couldnt have come at a better time in my life.
Thanks for this, it's helped me greatly in my revision - Test is tomorrow! eek!
H
If you don't understand that these aren't simply "ramblings", then you're not going to get particularly far with the exam. Carter uses Dora in a manner as such to pull in the reader; she is made to be as "human" as possible, her personality and tangents simply add to the character in my opinion.
I'm personally not looking forward to the exam, I'm hoping to pass it at least; if I do but with a really low pass I'll probably try and retake, but I think my final grade will depend on the question asked. I'm really confident in about half the possible questions and will fail horribly if I get one of the other questions.
Good luck to everyone who's sitting/resitting the exam tomorrow! Now... back to revision...
We have only just started it, but I'm already enjoying it immensely.
I found this page by accident, but I have put your quote about Carter's work cutting like a steel blade at the base of a man's penis into my essay.
My teacher LOVES that kind of thing, so thanks!
=)
I was told to read the book over half term, and i just cant get into it at all, i find myself reading the same lines ove and over cos it just doesnt go into my head at all.
The atricle helped though, so thankyou, and those above who criticise for not being able to get into it, not everyone is going to find it as easy as you ok?
everyone's taste is different, and i dont appreciate being told to read something i'm not interested in, you read a book cos you want to, i think thats why its hard.
and i do agree, tis a little bit rambly.
toodles!
Kat xx
All we have to do is hope for the best and prepare for the worse.
And you touchy CARTER fans...GET A LIFE. Why don't you have a stif drink and put down them geeky glasses...lifes to short.
As for the person who wrote this...thankyou very much it was a good read.
xxxx
I like the book, now that I've finished reading it, and I think it's cleverly written and interesting. I have to admit the first chapter lost me completely and I hated it the first time reading it, my AS Level class said the same thing, but oce I got past that I found it good :)
Saying that however, I have the exam in January 2008 and I hope I don't have to resit it in June because there's only so many times you can read it... I really hope I pass :-S
I read 'Wise Children' and didnt like it at first because of all of the flashbacks & rushed nature of the narrative voice. But after re - reading, analysing & discussing the book i began to really like it.
I love how the story remains funny - even in parts where it is meant to be serious!
I am currently concluding my 3rd practice essay on 'Wise Children' and am glad i found this page woop!!!
Good luck to anyone else doing AS English Literature!
Luvvs
xxx
Thank you so much!
xxxxxxxxxxxx
Even though there were some decent passages in there, the whole thing felt like being stuck in a one-sided conversation with someone the wouldn't stop talking about themselves. I read it waiting for something to happen, other than a single, overlong piece of character establishment. The lack of any actual plot, the lack of tension and release, meant that there was nothing to follow, no shared experience with the protagonist other than the nostalgic rambling of a one-dimensional old woman. It was like having tea with my Nan, except that at my Nan's house I would at least have had pie.
Just because a story references Shakespeare doesn't mean it's any good. If the Chuckle Brothers included allusions to Troilus and Cressida in next week's show it still wouldn't be high art.
And the shoddy, lazy, ending. All the charcters turn up and say hello, like the end of The Muppet Show.
Had I not been required to read this book, I never would have got to the end. It felt weak in most respects. I now have to go and discuss it with the rest of the class. Joy of joys.
I think people who are doing it as part of their AS level course may not enjoy because you have to tear the book apart, I can no longer read 'A Handmaid's Tale' because of this, but it's a truely fantastic read!
just wanted to ask (for anyone who reads this) what the time period for the book is, like when is it supposed to end?
is it 1992 - thats when it was published?
would really appreciate any help! :)
xxx
Sympathy for those 17 year olds who are trying to read and understand a text that is really not suitable for their age group. Astonishment at their spelling and grammar - in most cases appalling. How can you study English when lacking a basic understanding of the language?
Encore sympathy for their attempts to understand a complex plot and themes, and for the poor tuition they seem to have received.
I studied Carter at university and like a couple of the other posters, believe this is a text for adults, not the AS syllabus. I love it, but then I love Carter's work. Multi-layered, complex, blackly funny.
For me, this novel is a celebration of life and I agree with those who say they enjoyed it when older and sympathise with 17 year olds who may struggle with the concept of such celebration when conveyed by a 75 year old.
Rock on Carter. I think you were the best female author of your generation.
Post a Comment